Charmy bee is part of the chaotix,along with Vector and Espio. He was seen in sonic heroes when Rouge makes the mistake of thinking Chaotix were after Eggman's treasure. He made another appearance in Shadow the Hedgehog where Vector told him to find 5 secret disks. What is on the disc is never explained, although it could have been about Space Colony ARK since there was a scene in the last story to Shadow the Hedgehog. He actually saved earth when he rams his stinger into the computer activating the messsage Gerald left Shadow. Charmy also strongly looks up to Shadow and sees him as a role-modle.